You’ve got two bids in front of you.
- One contractor wants to install a new roof over your old one.Â
- The other wants to strip it down to the deck.Â
They can’t both be right, and the wrong choice costs you twice: once now, and again in three years when the roof underneath fails anyway.
So what’s the right answer? Well, it’s about what’s happening under the surface of the roof you already have.
What an overlay actually is
An overlay, also called a recover, puts a new roofing system on top of the existing one. It costs less upfront because there’s no tear-off labor or disposal. But it only works if the roof underneath is dry, structurally sound, and properly attached. An overlay doesn’t fix a bad roof. It hides one, for a while.
What a tear-off actually is
A tear-off strips the building down to the deck. It costs more, but it’s the only way to find out what’s really going on: rotted wood, rusted fasteners, saturated insulation, a deck that was never right to begin with.
When we handled the roof replacement at Monadnock Orthodontics in Peterborough, the job meant coordinating a full solar panel removal and reinstallation around the work, inspecting the deck, laying new underlayment, and sealing every penetration before the panels went back up. That kind of access is only possible with a tear-off.
Why New Hampshire makes this decision higher stakes
New Hampshire commercial roofs don’t fail gently. Snow sits on low-slope roofs, melts during the day, and refreezes at night, and the National Weather Service points to that freeze-thaw cycle as the mechanism behind ice dams backing water up under roof edges.
Nor’easters hit hardest from September through April, bringing wind-driven rain that finds every weak seam. An overlay installed on top of a compromised deck doesn’t survive a New Hampshire winter, it just delays the failure until the worst possible month.
The enemy here isn’t the roof. It’s the quote that skips the inspection.
Any contractor can recommend the cheaper option without checking what’s underneath it. That’s not a decision, it’s a guess with your building attached to it. We’ve replaced flat rubber commercial roofs, like the EPDM system and siding we installed for Black Forest Café in Amherst, and steep-slope commercial asphalt systems, like the architectural shingle roof at Milford Orthodontics.
Different systems, same rule: we don’t recommend a scope until we know what the deck and insulation are actually doing.
What this costs
Commercial roof replacement in New Hampshire typically runs $9,000 to $55,000 or more, depending on square footage, material, and what the deck inspection turns up. An overlay will usually land toward the lower end of that range. A tear-off costs more upfront, but it’s the only option that tells you the truth about what you’re protecting.
Before you approve either scope, ask your contractor:
- How many roofing layers are already on the building?
- Has anyone actually inspected the deck, or just the surface?
- Is any insulation wet or compressed?
- Will the added weight or height of an overlay interfere with drainage, flashing, or rooftop equipment?
- What does the warranty cover, the new material or the whole system?
If your roof is dry, single-layer, and draining properly, an overlay can be the right call. If it’s leaking, layered, or you genuinely don’t know what’s underneath, a tear-off is the only way to stop guessing.
Get a Quote from Our NH Roofing Contractors
Not sure which one your building needs? Conde Roofing & Construction will inspect the roof, tell you what we find, and recommend the scope that actually matches it, not the one that’s easier to sell. Call 603-838-ROOF to schedule a commercial roofing consultation.